1041 Days...

1041 Days...

That is exactly the number of days that it took to bring the last perpetrator to book from the day he, along with nine others came onto Colaba in inflatable speedboats and rook over their 'targets' and committed the most daring attack aimed at the business capital of the country in order to gather international attention and to put to practice his ISI-Pak Army training of "kill to the last breath". I have seen a lot of reactions to this act of serving the sentence upon Mohammad Ajmal Amir Kasab. One can recall the reactions right from 26/11/2008 when the wounds were fresh and a shell shocked country saw things unfolding right in their drawing rooms. Emotions ran high. Heart overpowered head. It was a mob hysteria that at that time stated that he should be hung in full public view for the world to showcase that India is not weak and cannot be played around with, especially by a country which uses terrorism as a state policy. It was a mentality of 'show me the blood' that existed at that time, rightly so. As days passed by, the voices got shriller to hang Kasab. Reason? Details of the way he was being kept in Arthur Road jail, the way he behaved in the courts, and the large amounts that were spent to keep him alive. There were online petitions, Facebook/Twitter/social media posts, making a mockery of the existence of Kasab in the jails. He laughed at the judges, behaved moody while in court rooms during the trial, was provided with biryani, all this at the expense of the exchequer.

Right from day one, from the time he was captured, it was the right things that the Indian state has done. I do not say Union government nor the state government of Maharashtra because it was the Home minister of the same Union government who was so incapable that he had to be shunted out and it was the CM of the state government who gave a 'guided tour' of the horror to a film director. But, as I always believed, and still do, that it is the statute, the constitution that has always stood up and it is because of the constitution of India that India still exists. It has never let me down. Even when people were getting impatient during the days of the seize and wanted him to be shot right then and there, or later when the trial started and so did the tantrums of this person started and people were shocked that he was being served biryani while the families of the victims (including that of high profile IPS officers) were still running from office to office, babu to babu just to get what was due to them, be it jobs or compensation, the decibel levels of people asking for his blood has gone up, I still had faith in the government. Yes it took 665 days for the case to be heard and a judgment pronounced. No lawyer came forward to represent Kasab in courts, to the extent that one of the local bar council has passed a resolution that none of its members would take up this case. Finally, some lawyers came forward after legal luminaries like Fali Nariam and some others and tried to point out that for it to be a fair trial; Kasab should have legal assistance in the form of a lawyer. People have even gone to the extent of attacking the lawyers who came forward to argue 'for' Kasab. Finally the trial started with the voices of 'hang Kasab' playing in the background. As time passed by, those voices again started getting louder as people started getting impatient. But here are the reasons that make me have a sense of immense pride in the constitution of India:

- There is a difference between a law abiding state and a terrorist or a state that sponsors terrorism and it has always been kept intact

- Had Kasab been killed on the spot or right during the course of the attack being unraveled, how could India prove to the world that these were Pakistanis? Everyone knows that these are Pakistanis, but, for it to be fair as per any court of law, there need to be 'proof'. I know it sounds funny when someone asks you to prove something like, say, pain, but, that’s how it works

- Had Kasab not been provided with all the evidence, case, and most importantly a lawyer before pronouncing the death penalty, how different would the Indian state be from those terrorists? At the end of the day, both would have fit the bill when someone wrote 'they killed a group of people irrationally'

- Had all the legal options not been exhausted before executing Kasab, how could the Indian constitution be upheld? After all, we take pride in our constitution. The legal recourse was that the trial court had to pronounce a judgment, then, Kasab should have recourse, and then if it won’t be in his favor in the High Court he should have recourse in the form of a Presidential review. It is only after this door closes should he be executed and that’s precisely what happened

Yes there was a delay, it took 2 years to pronounce the judgment, but, it is a quick one by looking at the backlog of cases in Indian courts. Yes, he was kept as if he was a 'state guest' as many said, but, if he was not treated fairly, then what is the difference between a terrorist outfit which abducts people and the world's largest democracy? At the end, he was executed after all the legal options were exhausted, he was executed as per the jail manuals that are in line with any human rights court, and he was executed while respecting Islamic religious sentiments.

If I have vociferously argued and debated with my friends against the way Saddam Hussein was executed by the US and NATO, if I have argued against Mamur Gaddafi being executed by the rebel troops, in the same breath I say that Kasab was executed as per law and no law was breached, not even a wee bit. There is the most powerful country on the face of the earth which could not or did not have the will to capture its most wanted criminal alive but instead chose to eliminate him and give him a 'at sea burial'. Then, there is India which followed all the laws - personal, human rights and religious laws. This puts India ahead of a lot of countries on the 'ethical and follow the land of the law to the 'T' quotient'.

But, alas! Not many are ready to acknowledge the greatness of this constitution, let alone take pride in it. I saw people distributing sweets, dancing, celebrating today’s event. There were politicians jumping at the first moment asking for the status of Afzal Guru from the parliament attacks. Yes, the government played its game, firstly by advising the President on Kasab's case before Afzal Guru's or the other people whose petitions are piled up on Raisina Hill. Yes, they might have hurried on this as the Parliament is reconvening tomorrow. But, don't forget that this is the land where the Buddha walked and no one has a right to seek another's life. This execution happened because the statute allowed (and still allows) capital punishment. But talking of lynching him or shooting him in public are jingoistic and uncalled for. I would want to end this post by quoting Anna Hazaare, the 'super hero' of the urban middle class and asking a question to the reader if it is correct to say "Kasab should have been hanged publicly"? I certainly feel it is not the right mindset and proves the immaturity of the people who say that.

Remember, the difference between a terrorist and a state is that the terrorist can choose a place, time and mode of carrying out menace, but, the state needs to prove the guilt however evident it is lest it becomes another terrorist state. This execution can utmost get a sense of completion to the kin of the victims, but, it is not something that should lead to joy and celebration.

Satyameva Jayate... Truth Prevails! Long live Indian Constitution.

A Tribute To The Milkman Of India

There have ever been only two milkmen whose fame has been unmatched. Both of them belonged to India and had chosen the same part of India - Gujarat as their 'karma bhoomi'. One is Lord Shri Krishna and the other is Dr. Verghese Kurien. There have been a good amount of obituaries on Verghese in the media after his death yesterday, 9th Sep. 2012. Here is my take on this great man who changed the face of India in many ways and impacted the way agriculture was done - just as any other business enterprise.




1. Dairy: India's Dairy farming had the best moment when Verghese Kurien, being his stubborn self, has insisted on processing and converting milk to milk powder. This he did inspite of the so called 'best in industry' - Nestle and scientists from New Zealand said it that it is bound to fail. He was proud to be stubborn. What started as a small revolution in a small milk cooperative in Gujarat's rural heartland has, in no time transformed into what we know as the White Revolution. It changed India from a milk importer to the largest producer of milk on earth. Till date business schools across the world are amazed and do case studies on the way Indian dairy industry transformed it self



The Times of India has famously quoted that when it asked Dr. Kurien to pose along with a cow for one of its featured articles, he insisted on posing with a buffalo. The reason being that it was the buffalo that changed the face of Indian dairy industry and was instrumental in getting India to self sufficiency in dairy



2. Processed Food: It wont be untrue if I say that this industry started with Dr. Kurien. His insistence of processing milk to milk powder so that milk can be stored for a longer period in time coupled with the transportation/logistics/storage/supply chain associated with this industry were all a result of his vision. It is said that Nestle has declared the idea of converting buffalo milk to milk powder was a failure to begin with. The world until that time has known of milk powder made out of cow milk which was more freely available in Europe and ANZ, the two biggest dairy cultivating countries until that time. I read somewhere that he stormed out of Nestlé’s board meeting when his idea of 'milk to milk powder' was termed as a failure. We were fortunate that he stuck to his guns. It is very important for a country like India to focus more on storage and processing of food so that we eliminate poverty and malnutrition from our country. This is more relevant in this day and time when there is a big debate on FDI in retail and the advantages that it might get to the entire food processing and supply chain system



3. Cooperatives: Verghese Kurien has not just been instrumental in Operation Flood or the White Revolution but he was also instrumental in the 'cooking oil revolution' of India which was done under the 'Dhara' umbrella whereas the dairy revolution was under the 'Amul' umbrella



It was this cooperative movement that started well before the micro-credit program by the Bangladeshi Grameena Bank started by Muhammad Yunus was in limelight. This was the cooperative movement that empowered women and small time farmers and got them the bargaining power that they needed to stand to their point against the middlemen and big milk producers/companies. The revolution on the oil front was not as huge as the milk revolution and the reasons attributed to this is the politics of the big fish in this game and the political lobbying.



4. Rural Management: It was another examples of the Malayalee visionary who did not understand Gujarati when he embarked on his journey of transforming India. He has made the Gujarati old man very proud with his vision and the need that he felt that Indian agriculture, cooperatives and rural development needed professional management a la any other corporate entity. This is the basis on which IRMA, one of the best known institutes of its kind in the world was formed. Yes, Indian agriculture and rural development needs professional management. Can anyone deny that? Has anyone thought about this need earlier? This is what makes Dr. Kurien an extraordinary visionary.



An offshoot result of his vision is the 'Amul Cartoons' which are considered as a corner stone of Indian advertising history - with a cartoon and an Amul girl commenting on the issues of the day. The day when Dr. Kurien passed away, the cartoon paid him a tribute with:

Dr. Varghese Kurien rightly deserves a Bharat Ratna. He is one, even without being awarded that. He shall remain a ratna in the hearts of the millions of the three million odd small time farmers who are members of the cooperative that he has founded. Let’s not forget that one of the greatest pacifists to have walked on this earth, another Gujarati, has never been awarded the greatest peace prize of this planet. But, that has not belittled him. Nor would government recognition of the contribution of Dr. Kurien will endorse his dedication. If the government chooses to award him with a Bharat Ratna, albeit posthumously, then, in reality it will be recognizing itself.

Tried my hand at sketching after a long long time... guess I still didn't forget that one. :)

Top 5 Biggest Moments of 2011 that will show an impact on India in 2012

5 - Jasmine Revolution: Its this name given to the revolution that happened in Tunisia which lead to a string of revolutions now collectively called 'Arab Spring'

Keep an eye, this string of revolutions are bound to have an increased NATO/US interference in the Middle East and it will create a much more dangerous world though it will weed out a lot of dictators at the end of it. It will show an effect on the oil prices but more importantly, with Indian Foreign/External Affairs babu's and ministers what they are - incompetent, will show an impact on India's stature as a world power and its relation with some of the oldest countries of the world

4 - Inflation/Price Rise: No one has a clue where this is headed and if it would halt and when it would slow down, if at all. If there is a hike continuously for a couple of weeks, a prompt mandarins from the Govt., either the Planning Commission SPOC Montek or the FM himself comes out and says 'we expect it to come down in the next couple of months' and we wait like a Godot

3 - Change of guard: Be it NRN calling it a day and handling the mantle to KV Kamath or one Premji passing the baton to the other Premji, or Ratan hanging his boots and getting the highest taxpayer of Ireland and a foreign national to head what is now a true 'Indian Multinational' and sit in the hot seat at Bombay House, it is a real change of guard and it will give a different direction to corporate India

2 - Money Money: Euro collapsing thanks to Greece, Italy and the 'weak block' and creating a 'class within a class' by making Euros of Germany more favorable than the rest, or our own Indian Rupee tumbling not just because of any recessionary pressure but because of political reasons and under performing stock exchange leading to flight of capital out of the country, it has been a very strong negativism that is seen all around. FDI fiasco added to it in Indian context

1 - Corruption: The 10 letter word that made a government to goof up big time, an 'aspiring father of nation' and his courtiers to hold a country and its parliament to ransom, an opposition to get a point to play dirty as they got an issue after a long long time, some senseless dharnas and mobs and ill-informed crowds come out in hundreds without knowing what they are supporting for, but, just displaying a khadi cap or a caption 'I am Anna' a fad even in fashion circles, culminating in taking the Rajya Sabha into the darkest moments it might have ever seen on the last working day of the year at the stroke of midnight hour. There were the Kalmadi's, Raja's, Kanni's, Gali's who shined like 'crazy diamonds' in 'Corruption's Hall of Shame'

Liberation - Making Sure Nothing Else Matters!

yam hi na vyathayanty ete purusam purusarsabha
sama-duhkha-sukham dhiram so 'mrtatvaya kalpate

O best among men [Arjuna], the person who is not disturbed by happiness and distress and is steady in both is certainly eligible for liberation

Liberation - One word, powerful, deep and is thought provoking. If one is trying to liberate a person, a country, a thing or an animal, then it is very simple. You free the person, country, thing, animal, bird, whatever. But how about liberating one-self? How can you liberate your own self? How can I liberate me? What do I liberate me from? How do I do that? Is it possible? One can easily liberate anything else but one’s own self. In order to do that, one needs to recognize the fact that we are not liberated. But are we really not liberated? Let us put this question the other way round. Are we bound by anything? If one says no, then they are bluffing, nothing else. Are we not bound by our own self? Yes we are. We are bound by many material things, relations, thoughts, and above all we are bound by our greed and our fears and ambitions. If we go and wish and pray, what do we wish for? Almost all the time we wish for comforts, money, relations, success, promotions, material things, what not? We also go to the extent of ‘bribing’ Him. What a joke! How can you even think of asking for material things and sundry when He has made you for a purpose? And to top it, we go to the extent of bribing Him so that he gives us what we want! Wow! How narrow can we get in our mindset?

The day we bid adieu to this material world, we do not take any money, any materialistic things no matter how big or small and also no relation. All we take with us is us, our soul. Not anything more, and not anything less. Annamacharya, a Telugu composer and musician, in one of his songs slaps it in our face when he says ‘it’s the same sleep that even a King or a pauper sleeps. It’s the same place where all of us end up – no matter what our birth and life has been’. All you need is at the most that 7x3 piece of land. That is all you need, or to put it better, that is all your body needs.

But for our soul, it’s a different story all together. It can be liberated, in its true sense. A person with a liberated soul will be totally unattached. Nothing can shake him. Nothing can affect him.  Happiness, sorrow, ups and downs, wealth, poverty, relations, all of them has the same influence on him – none of them matter. None of them can shake him to either side. He is always elated. Constantly. For him, sorrows and distress does not depress him or even shake him; and at the same time he would not fly in air, to cloud # 9. His feet are firmly set on the ground, to reality as it exists. Mind you it is reality as it exists and not as is perceived.

To quote Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan on this verse ‘… remains the same in pain and pleasure, who is wise makes himself fit for eternal life. Eternal life is different from survival of death which is given to every embodied being. It is the transcendence of life and death. To be subject to grief and sorrow, to be disturbed by the material happenings, to be deflected by them from the path of duty that has to be traversed, ‘nityam karma’, shows that we are still victims of ‘avidya’ or ignorance’.

It is the simplest thing not to be influenced by things around. But, it is the toughest thing to stay immune. Take it as you like. The day everything is equal and does not affect you is the day when you have opened for yourself the doors of eternity. And eternity need not be heaven after you are gone. It also can be sheer bliss. That is the ultimate truth and ultimate knowledge. Everything else is your perception.

This is my take on Verse 15, chapter 2 of the Gita :)

STOP TACTICS, THEATRICS AND BLACKMAILS! PLEASE! GOVERMENT & ALSO HAZARE TEAM! INDIAN CONSTITUION & DEMOCRACY ARE AT STAKE!

STOP TACTICS, THEATRICS AND BLACKMAILS! PLEASE! GOVERMENT & ALSO HAZARE TEAM! INDIAN CONSTITUION & DEMOCRACY ARE AT STAKE! by Sridhar Patel on Friday, August 26, 2011 at 3:10pm Mr Hazare: What next? Want to 'gherao' parliament? If your condition is to pass a bill that ONLY YOUR bill be passed, NEED NOT NECESSARILY THE BEST OMBUDSMEN BILL, then why do we need a parliament? Why do we need to discuss? Why do we need any other pillar of democracy? We will make life simpler... If we need a solution for anything, we will go on an 'indefinite fast' (Mind you: It is not a 'fast unto death'. Not sure of the choice of words by the team B of jokers). We will get a law without a discussion, and get santri to CJI under its ambit, blackmail, instigate, provoke people at the same time say 'I am peace loving'. If a 'Gandhian' says 'gherao parliament, MP's, 7 RCR, then poor old Gandhi must be turning in his grave now that his last name hijacked and mistaken for another family and now if his idealism too is hijacked. Did anyone who blidnly get carried away by this wave know the meaning of an 'Ombudsman' (English for 'Lok pal') mean? Merriam Webster defines an Ombudsman as: 1: a government official (as in Sweden or New Zealand) appointed to receive and investigate complaints made by individuals against abuses or capricious acts of public officials 2: one that investigates, reports on, and helps settle complaints It DOES NOT say get Judiciary. It is not a way to get judiciary under a Lok pal. If say one doctor was reported a quack in a newspaper, does that mean that the next time you visit a doctor, you ask him to prove he is a doctor? Yes, judges too can be corrupt. But you cannot get them under an ombudsman. Get judicial reforms for that. Nothing else. Even if you drop this, it still does not give you a right to subvert the Constitution of India and Democratic System of India. Those are supreme. Politicians have let the country down and do not forget, We, Indians have let the country down (by making corruption a way of life and 'chaltaa hai', 'jugaad' as part of our life). It is not the other way round. If you say ALL politicians are corrupt, then why on earth did you elect them? Or is it that you didn't even vote? Do not even attempt to hijack the parliament. A lady tried doing it in the mid 70's and left an indelible mark on the face of India called Emergency. Next thing is to get this Lokpal to cover all the states. Remember Indian constitution says that (and I quote the preamble) India is a Sovereign, Socialist, Secular, Democratic, Republic. It is a an amalgamation of Federal and Union structure. How can Centre force states to go for Lokayuktas? That is a state subject for God's sake! Go to the states and fight it over there. Please start it with the North East. That is the most alienated part of the country. Can you? Would you? And Mr. Kejriwal, stop your arrogance and SHUT UP. It is not as much that the governments inaction that is hurting the health of Hazare but your arrogant ways. Whenever I see you talking, I am reminded of the climax scene of a Hindi movie 'Guide' where Raju is forced to go on a fast for rains without his will and wish and then, not let to eat until it rains. By the time it starts raining, people forget that there is someone fasting until death and he is forgotten, and the poor guy dies in a bid to become immortal. Please do not let this old guy die like that for your aspirations. Indian rural society needs more and more of people like Hazare to improve their standard of living - irrigation, grain banks, strengthening grass roots democracy and much more. Lastly, surprise from the most unlikeliest of quarters. Yes, why not make the ombudsman a constitutional body? Prince Gandhi might have had a great media manager and a political advisor who have planted this thought, or he himself might have gotten a 'Eureka' moment, but, I care the least where it came from. But, if the Election Commission is spotless, if the Lokayukata has been spotless, if the CAT (Central Administrative Tribunal) is spotless, if CVC is spotless (Thomas had to quit, and that is because of the checks and balances in the Law and not because he wanted to quit or not because the government wanted him to go), why not have a constitutional body of Lok pal? Think! Act sensibly! Please! India deserves nothing but the best. Let it get it out of discussions, and brainstorming, but not with blackmails.

I SUPPORT ANTI-CORRUPTION, BUT I DO NOT SUPPORT ANNA HAZARE

Extracts from my Facebook notes and discussions: I SUPPORT ANTI-CORRUPTION, BUT I DO NOT SUPPORT ANNA HAZARE by Sridhar Patel on Friday, August 19, 2011 at 2:54pm At the cost of being unpopular, let me be clear: I am a 100% supporter of any anti-corruption movement but, I DO NOT SUPPORT Kisan Baburao - Anna Hazare. Corruption is the biggest leach of Indian society, polity and economy. Agreed. But people who are naming this as the second Independence movement, do you know the difference between Independence movement and a social cleansing mechanism? There is a need for better anti corruption law, but, I DO NOT support Anna, his ways and his theatrics. You have done your part, woke the urban society. Thank you for that. But that is it. Agreed that the entire political spectrum in the country is corrupt, but, you and your team should not cross the line and try to be law makers. If you want to be a law maker, get elected and get into the House. DO NOT try to do it using the blackmail tactics. You do not even represent the entire civil society. Do not forget the Aruna Roy's version of Lokpal is far better than yours but did not get as much air time and remains largely unheard of. Do not try to take the place of the new Father of the Nation. There have been better contenders for that (JP) who could not fit in those shoes.You wont too. History will remember you as the one who got the urban masses educated on the need for anti-corruption bill. Be happy with it. YOU DO NOT DESERVE BEYOND THAT. In response to a friend's comment on this post where he said that I seem to be a Congress supporter, I wrote: I am equally irritated with both the family run businesses (one of Gandhi's and the other one being Sangh). I do not like the 'Rahul Bhajan Mandali' along with the guy himself who lacks experience and is no different from any other person if that family tag is removed nor do I like the octogenrain who ideally should have retired by now along with his senior but who is still sitting in the Lok Sabha with the single wish of doing a 'house warming ceremony' at 7RCR. But I have always liked certain individuals and I do not have any qualms about it. I do not even think twice when I say that AB Vajpayee and PV Narasimha Rao were the best PM's that India ever had. Both of them have had cases of inaction against them (one where the Centre was sleeping when a centuries old structure was being demolished with 'ek dhakka aur do, babri masjid tod do!' slogans running high and the other where the External Affairs minister of the country escorts a dreaded terrorist and a bus over the Gangetic plains and Punjab lead to the hills of Kashmir). They made history in more than one way. Yes, Man was the best FM our country had in the recent times but his self confessed helplessness and coalition compulsions have deprived him of being a good PM. There is no ways about the black money, 3G, CWG, Air India, and all the other scams and the rampant corruption that is running the show. I also mentioned in my note that I do not subscribe to the rampant corruption of this government and nor do I support the ways they are using to handle situations. Especially the way jokers like Ambica Soni, Kapil Sibal, Singhvi, and the gang are handling the government. I guess they never heard of the saying 'It is better to shut you mouth and let people wonder if you are a fool, rather than opening your mouth and confirming that'. As I said, I do support the anti corruption awareness of the day and thank Anna Hazare for that. But, nothing more. That does not mean that I want an anti corruption bill which is not the best around and which can jeopardize the working of any government. I want a government that works on its own and looks after its people any day vis-a-vis a government that would not act and cannot act on anything because even the judiciary comes under a 'super power' called Lokpal. If that is the case then why would you need a parliament, a judiciary or an executive? Lets do away with all of them and create one Lokpal. But what after that? Who will monitor them? If you want judiciary to monitor the executive and a parliament to monitor the judiciary and a Lokpal to monitor the parliamentarians (including the PMO) then that is fine. But if you want to do away with all the existing structure and bodies and get even the judiciary under its perview, then I am sorry. I wont subscribe to it. There should be checks and balances. Correct. But, there should not be any Frankenstine monsters around. We are better without them. I was sharing this with one of my other friends the other day, and I say that here again - corruption has become a part and parcel of our lives. The same people (including you and I) who brag about corruption do not mind bribing a constable for a 'petty traffic offense'. We find it absolutely fine when we say 'do this bit of work and I will give you an extra chocolate' to a kid. We do not even spare God when we say 'I will break a 100 coconuts if you do xyz to me'. We do not realize that all that is ALSO bribing. If you want to fight corruption, start it with a 'No' at home. I said that I thank that guy (Anna Hazare) for the awareness that he generated with the urban folks. But he does not deserve beyond it. If he wants to be a law maker. Let him be one. It is easy to sit in Ramlila Maidan and give a speach. It is a totally different story to sit in Parliament and discuss a bill. If you are saying that MP's are corrupt, I ask who got them there and who made them corrupt in the first place? If putting the bill for discussion in the parliament is the aim, then, why can't an MP (Agnivesh is a strong supporter of his and an MP too) put the so called 'Jan Lokpal' as a private member bill? Then the parliament will have to discuss it. But no, that will take the fizz out, the TRP's will fall for these news channels, and Anna will have to go back to his crusade of agricultural reforms, creating water banks, fighting for the rural issues in the Maharashtra heartland and he is good at that. But, the only problem being he won't get this publicity and attention to do theatrics. Think! :)